Dvaarik is self-serve SaaS today: there is no setup fee and no minimum commitment. You log in, add your services, staff, hours and knowledge, connect channels, and pay only for what your agents actually do. | What | Price | Notes | |---|---|---| | Setup fee | ₹0 | Self-serve — configure your business from the dashboard | | AI voice calls | from ₹2/min | Simple per-minute billing on whole minutes; higher grades up to ₹5/min | | AI chat | ₹2 per conversation | 24-hour window | | Phone number + 1 concurrent line | ₹1,500 per 30 days | Includes up to 3 numbers; debited from credits | | Social Plan — WhatsApp + Instagram agents + campaigns | ₹1,500 per 30 days | Only if you use those channels | | WhatsApp message charges | ₹0 markup | Meta bills your own WhatsApp Business account directly | Credits are prepaid and never expire; at zero balance agents pause gracefully, so there are no surprise bills. Agencies and developers can sell the same platform under their own brand through the white-label partner programme, and set their own client pricing.
What does a Tamil AI voice agent cost in India?
Dvaarik is self-serve SaaS today: there is no setup fee and no minimum commitment. You log in, add your services, staff, hours and knowledge, connect channels, and pay only for what your agents actually do.
| What | Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| AI voice calls | from ₹2/min | Simple per-minute billing on whole minutes; higher grades up to ₹5/min |
| AI chat | ₹2 per conversation | 24-hour window |
| Phone number + 1 concurrent line | ₹1,500 per 30 days | Includes up to 3 numbers; debited from credits |
| Social Plan — WhatsApp + Instagram agents + campaigns | ₹1,500 per 30 days | Only if you use those channels |
| WhatsApp message charges | ₹0 markup | Meta bills your own WhatsApp Business account directly |
The comparison above states the published row-by-row differences; read each row with its source, date, and qualifying notes.
Credits are prepaid and never expire; at zero balance agents pause gracefully, so there are no surprise bills. Agencies and developers can sell the same platform under their own brand through the white-label partner programme, and set their own client pricing.
Why some vendors charge more for Tamil, and why we do not
The mechanism is worth understanding before you compare any two quotes, because it explains why a headline rate can be true and still not apply to you.
An AI voice agent is assembled from speech recognition, a language model and a synthetic voice. A vendor pays for each of those per language it deploys, and Hindi and English are the two with the widest supply. The commercial consequence is that many India vendors treat Hindi and English as what the base price covers, and put the regional languages either in a higher plan tier or in a bespoke add-on. Nothing about that is dishonest — it is a real cost shape — but it means a rate quoted to you for "AI calling" may not be the rate that applies once you say the calls are in Tamil.
Three examples, all read on the vendor's own pages and dated:
- Agni by Ravan.ai gates language by tier: its pricing page shows "Hindi + English (Starter) · All 30+ Indian languages (Growth+)". Starter is ₹2,999/mo with 300 minutes and ₹8/min overage; Growth is ₹5,999/mo with 1,000 minutes and ₹6/min overage (ravan.ai/pricing, checked 21 Jul 2026). On their published structure, Tamil starts at the Growth tier.
- Botsense does the same: its Starter plan is described as "Hindi + English support" at ₹9/min, while the Growth plan at ₹7/min is the one listed with "10+ languages including Hindi, Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Bengali, Marathi" (botsense.io/ai-calling-pricing/, checked 21 Jul 2026).
- Scalify Labs writes on its pricing blog that "Hindi + English is standard", and lists "Custom language/dialect support beyond Hindi + English" under what is "typically charged extra" (scalifylabs.com/blog/ai-calling-pricing-india-2026, checked 21 Jul 2026).
That same Scalify page states that "Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Marathi, Bengali typically add ₹0.10–₹0.20/min premium depending on the platform and voice quality required". Read that sentence precisely: it is Scalify describing what they observe across the market, not Scalify publishing a surcharge of their own. We are flagging it because it is the clearest published statement that a regional-language premium exists as a market norm in India, and because a page-1 search result saying so will shape what you expect to be quoted. It would be a fabrication to report it as any single vendor's own policy, and we are not doing that.
Our position, stated as a term rather than a boast
Tamil is billed at ₹2 per minute on Bharat Standard, the same rate as English and Hindi, from the very first minute — no voice plan, no minimum volume, no lock-in. Tamil does not move you to a higher plan, does not require a bespoke language package, and does not change price at any volume.
And the honest qualifier, so this section survives being quoted on its own: charging no language premium is not something only we do. Trikon publishes Tamil inside a language list it labels "included free" at a flat ₹5/min — "Hindi, Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Bengali & 10+ languages — included free" (trikon.tech/voice-pricing-comparison); their India page names 11 languages in all, being 10 Indian languages plus Indian-accent English (trikon.tech/ai-voice-agent-india), both checked 21 Jul 2026. HuskyVoice's entry plan at ₹1,999/month lists "30+ Indian & International Languages" as included (huskyvoice.ai/use-cases/franchise-voice-ai, checked 21 Jul 2026). If your shortlist includes those, language coverage is not the axis that will separate them from us. Price and terms are.
What do other India vendors charge for a Tamil-speaking voice agent?
Only figures we read on the vendor's own pages are in this table, each with the terms attached. Anything we could not verify at source is marked as not published rather than estimated.
| Vendor | Where Tamil sits on their published structure | Published price | Terms attached |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dvaarik | Base tier. Tamil = ₹2/min, same as English and Hindi | ₹2/min, plus ₹1,500 per 30 days if we supply the number | no voice plan, no minimum volume, no lock-in. Whole-minute billing. Prices ex-GST; 18% GST at credit load |
| Trikon | Tamil named inside a language list labelled "included free"; their India page names 11 languages in all — 10 Indian plus Indian-accent English | ₹5/min flat | no voice subscription and no setup fee published. Telephony/DID "billed separately by your carrier" — the ₹5 is not your landed cost |
| Edesy | 8+ Indian languages on the pay-as-you-go tier | ₹6/min pay-as-you-go, page headline "₹4-6 Per Minute" | Plus telephony at $0.07/min as published. Minimum recharge ₹500. A ₹20,000 onboarding package is also sold, which converts to ₹20,000 of credits |
| Agni by Ravan.ai | "All 30+ Indian languages (Growth+)"; Starter is Hindi + English | Growth ₹5,999/mo incl. 1,000 min, ₹6/min overage | Subscription is the only published route. ₹2/min appears only on quote-only Enterprise at 10,000+ minutes. Telephony published separately as a pass-through |
| Botsense | Tamil named on the Growth plan; Starter is Hindi + English | Growth ₹7/min; Starter ₹9/min; Enterprise ₹5/min | "No monthly commitment" published. Growth capped at "up to 10,000 minutes/month". No GST treatment and no rounding rule published |
| VaniAgent | 27 Indian languages claimed — a larger count than ours | ₹4.5–5.5/min on a Metered Credits tier at ₹4,999/month | Prices exclude 18% GST. The unlimited plans carry a 3-month minimum. Whether ₹4,999 includes credits is not published, so no total is computed here |
| Bolna AI | "10+ vernacular Indian languages including Hinglish, Hindi, Tamil, Telugu" | 6.00¢/min, displayed on their own page as ₹5.52/min | Their docs state total cost also includes telephony and a Bolna platform fee whose amount is not published |
| HuskyVoice.AI | "30+ Indian & International Languages" in the entry plan | ₹1,999/month entry plan, 100 voice credits at 2 credits = 1 minute | ₹4/min is published strictly as "Enterprise volume pricing as low as ₹4/min", not an entry rate. Overage rate beyond the included credits is not published |
| Scalify Labs | "Custom language/dialect support beyond Hindi + English" listed as typically charged extra | ₹0.40/min headline | Their own page labels its rates "estimates. always get a formal quote". Voice minutes bill on top of a plan from ₹15,000/month, with ₹15,000–₹40,000 setup, a 10,000 min/month minimum and a 3-month commitment |
| MyOperator | "English, Hindi, Hinglish + 9 Indian languages" | No ₹/min figure published anywhere; voice overage published as ₹8 per conversation | Annual-billed subscription |
| SquadStack | Not published | No rupee figure published at all | Their FAQ states "the per-minute rate depends on language mix, call complexity, integration depth, and the engagement scale" — language mix is named as a pricing input |
The comparison above states the published row-by-row differences; read each row with its source, date, and qualifying notes.
All competitor figures verified on the named vendor's own pages on 21 Jul 2026 and recorded with the sentence they came from. Competitor pricing in this market moves within weeks — re-check any figure here against the vendor's live page before you decide on it.
Three cautions about reading that table
- Scalify's ₹0.40/min is not an apples-to-apples per-minute rate. It carries their own estimate disclaimer, it covers Hindi and English on their published structure, and voice minutes are billed on top of a monthly plan starting ₹15,000. Comparing it directly against a pay-as-you-go rate would misrepresent them.
- HuskyVoice's ₹4/min is an at-volume enterprise floor, not their entry rate. Their published entry is ₹1,999/month for 100 voice credits; at their own stated 2 credits = 1 minute that is 50 included minutes, which is our arithmetic from their published figures and not a rate they quote.
- Agni's ₹2/min shares our headline number but not our terms. Their pricing page places ₹2/min on the Custom Enterprise tier and their homepage qualifies it as the "Enterprise volume rate at 10,000+ minutes"; the buyable entry is ₹2,999/mo with ₹8/min overage. We are stating that neutrally because it is a documented structure, not an accusation.
SquadStack aside, notice what almost no one in that table does: publish a rate next to the word Tamil. That is the gap this page exists to close. Our own multi-vendor workings are in the India AI voice agent pricing index.
Three Tamil-speaking businesses, costed line by line
Dvaarik is self-serve SaaS today: there is no setup fee and no minimum commitment. You log in, add your services, staff, hours and knowledge, connect channels, and pay only for what your agents actually do.
| What | Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| AI voice calls | from ₹2/min | Simple per-minute billing on whole minutes; higher grades up to ₹5/min |
| AI chat | ₹2 per conversation | 24-hour window |
| Phone number + 1 concurrent line | ₹1,500 per 30 days | Includes up to 3 numbers; debited from credits |
| Social Plan — WhatsApp + Instagram agents + campaigns | ₹1,500 per 30 days | Only if you use those channels |
| WhatsApp message charges | ₹0 markup | Meta bills your own WhatsApp Business account directly |
The comparison above states the published row-by-row differences; read each row with its source, date, and qualifying notes.
Credits are prepaid and never expire; at zero balance agents pause gracefully, so there are no surprise bills. Agencies and developers can sell the same platform under their own brand through the white-label partner programme, and set their own client pricing.
What "supports Tamil" should mean before you pay for it
A language name in a feature list costs a vendor nothing to type. These are the things that actually break on a Tamil call, described as mechanisms rather than with invented pass rates. Test each of them on a live call before you buy from anyone, including us.
1. Spoken Tamil, not written Tamil. Tamil has a well-documented split between the formal literary register and the everyday spoken register, and they differ in vocabulary and verb endings, not just in accent. A system trained mainly on written text can produce Tamil that is grammatically correct and sounds like a news bulletin rather than a shopkeeper. Ask the agent a normal question and listen for whether it answers the way a person in the shop would.
2. Tanglish, mid-sentence. Tamil speakers routinely switch to English for the words that arrived in English — appointment, booking, delivery, EMI, WhatsApp, model number — and back to Tamil for everything else, inside one sentence. The test is not whether the agent speaks Tamil. It is whether it survives a caller who opens in Tamil, drops an English clause in the middle, and finishes in Tamil, without restarting or asking them to repeat.
3. No language menu. A keypad IVR that says "press 1 for Tamil" puts a decision in front of the caller before they have said anything. Our agent detects the language from the caller's first words and continues in it. If the caller switches, it follows.
4. Numbers, dates, money and time read back correctly. This is where language support most often fails silently. An agent that understands Tamil but reads back an appointment slot or an amount in a way the caller has to decode is creating errors, not removing them. Give it a date and an amount on the test call and listen to how it repeats them.
5. Local names it will actually hear. Callers say place names and street names, not pin codes. Whether the agent can capture a Velachery or a Tiruppur address, or a name it has never seen, is a better test of usefulness than any language count. So is whether it spells the name back for confirmation instead of guessing.
6. What it does when it does not understand. The honest behaviour is to say so and hand over to a person, not to improvise. Ask any vendor to demonstrate the failure path in Tamil, not just the happy path.
7. Regional variation. Tamil spoken in Chennai, Coimbatore, Madurai and Tirunelveli is not identical, and neither are the callers of a business in each. We are not going to publish a claimed accuracy figure by district, because we do not have one and neither does anyone else who is being straight with you. Test with your own callers, in your own town, before committing money.
More on how language handling works across our agents: multilingual and customers call in Telugu.
What the agent actually does on a Tamil call
Described mechanically, with no performance claims attached, because the price above only means something if you know what you are buying at ₹2 a minute.
Inbound
The agent answers every call, including outside working hours, identifies your business by name, and works through the flow you approved — answering the questions your counter answers every day, offering real open slots, holding a slot while it confirms details, and sending a WhatsApp confirmation on your own number. It handles the call in whatever language the caller opens in, and follows them if they switch.
Illustrative exchange, invented business ("Anbu Dental, Velachery"), showing the code-mixing that matters more than the language label:
> Caller: Saturday appointment kidaikuma, cleaning ku. > Agent: Anbu Dental, Velachery. Saturday 11:30 am illa 4:15 pm irukku, scaling appointment ku. Ethu convenient? > Caller: 4:15 pannunga. > Agent: 4:15 pm Saturday hold panren. Ungaloda peru sollunga, and confirmation ku WhatsApp number.
Outbound, with the conduct rules stated as rules
- We call only your own leads, customers and enquiries. No purchased lists, no scraped numbers, no cold databases, ever.
- The agent identifies your business by name at the start of every outbound call.
- Calling hours are set by you and respected.
- A person who asks not to be called again is marked and not called again by that campaign.
Speed-to-lead is the case where this earns its keep: an enquiry from an ad gets a call back in about 60 seconds, in Tamil, while the person is still holding the phone. Details on outbound calls.
Handover
The agent transfers to a person on request, without arguing, and does not pretend to be human. Some callers will ask for a person immediately and that is a normal outcome, not a failure. Configure the handover number on day one.
Billing behaviour, so there is no surprise
Talk time is billed in whole minutes at ₹2/min for Tamil. Ringing that never connects is not conversation time, but a connected call that ends in "call me later" is still billed talk time. If your calls are typically very short, whole-minute rounding is a real cost and you should factor it in — a 40-second Tamil call bills the same one minute as a 60-second one.
When a Tamil-speaking human, or another vendor, is the better buy
The subject described in this section: This page is only worth reading because this section is honest.
1. Your call volume is very low and you want one number on the bill. At 200–300 minutes a month our ₹1,500 number charge dominates, and a flat monthly plan may cost less in total and is certainly simpler to approve. HuskyVoice publishes an entry plan at ₹1,999/month including a TRAI-ready Indian number, 100 voice credits at 2 credits per minute, and 30+ Indian and international languages (huskyvoice.ai/use-cases/franchise-voice-ai, checked 21 Jul 2026). Those 100 credits work out to 50 included minutes — our arithmetic from their published inputs, not a figure they quote — so if 50 minutes covers your month, that is a legitimate choice and the arithmetic favours it.
2. You want zero commitments and already have a carrier. Trikon publishes a flat ₹5/min with no voice subscription and no setup fee, with telephony brought from your own carrier (trikon.tech/ai-voice-agent-india), and lists Tamil among the languages it labels "included free" (trikon.tech/voice-pricing-comparison), both checked 21 Jul 2026. If you already run Twilio, Plivo or another carrier and want nothing but a per-minute meter on top, that is a clean fit and worth pricing against us properly.
3. You need a bigger language footprint than Tamil plus the Indian set. VaniAgent claims 27 Indian languages, which is a larger published count than our 22 scheduled languages plus English (vaniagent.com, checked 21 Jul 2026). If your requirement genuinely spans more than the scheduled languages, count that in their favour.
4. Your calls are consultative and relationship-led. A Tamil-speaking human at a jewellery counter, a wedding hall or a high-value showroom reads hesitation, recognises a returning family, and negotiates. Software does not do any of that. The AI is worth having for the 9pm call, the second caller during the lunch rush, and the follow-up list nobody gets to — not as a replacement for the person your customers ask for by name.
5. You need proof it worked at a business like yours. We have no Tamil case study and no published outcome figures, because we are early and have a hard rule against publishing proof we do not have. Competitor pages will show you percentages; we would rather you call the live demo and judge the thing directly. That is a real disadvantage and you should weigh it.
6. You need heavy concurrency, an SLA and a support rota. Our default is one number and one line, with extra lines at ₹1,500 per month. That scales to a few lines, not to a call centre. Every agent is built personally by one engineer — see about — which is why you can reach the person who built it, and also why we are the wrong supplier for a company that needs a support organisation behind it.
Questions to ask any vendor that says it supports Tamil
Take this list to us and to everyone else. The answers separate vendors faster than a demo does.
- What is the per-minute rate for calls in Tamil specifically, in rupees, on a page I can read. If the Tamil rate differs from the English rate, ask for both numbers in writing.
- Which plan or tier do I have to be on before Tamil is available. Several India vendors publish Hindi and English on the entry tier and put other Indian languages higher up.
- Is there a language premium, a language package, or a bespoke-voice charge for Tamil.
- Is billing per second or per whole minute. Ours is whole minutes and we say so; rounding matters most if your calls are short.
- Is telephony included in the per-minute rate or billed separately. A ₹5/min quote with a carrier bill on top is not the same product as a rate that includes the number.
- What do I pay in month one before a single call is answered — setup, plan fee, number, minimum load, onboarding, and GST on top of all of it.
- Am I billed for ringing and unanswered calls, or only connected conversation.
- Play me a Tamil call where the caller code-switches into English mid-sentence. Then a call where the caller says something the agent does not understand.
- Where do WhatsApp message fees land — on the vendor's invoice with a markup, or on my own Meta account.
- Is there a lock-in or a minimum monthly volume, and do credits expire.
- Every statistic on your website — which business, what period, measured how. If it cannot be sourced, discount the page.
- Will you call numbers I did not give you. The only acceptable answer is no.
Related reading: AI calling agent price in India 2026, Hindi voice AI at ₹2/min, and the pricing page.
If you want to hear a Tamil call before you speak to anyone, the live demo is the only proof we offer, and we would rather you judge it than take our word: start from the pilot page or Log in to Dvaarik on WhatsApp at +91 79956 76588.
Frequently asked questions
How much does a Tamil AI voice agent cost per minute in India?
With Dvaarik, calls in Tamil are billed at ₹2 per whole minute of talk time — the Bharat Standard rate that covers the 22 scheduled Indian languages plus English — with no monthly subscription, no minimum volume and no lock-in. If Dvaarik supplies the phone number, add ₹1,500 per 30 days, auto-debited from prepaid credits. For comparison, rates read on other India vendors' own pages on 21 Jul 2026 include Trikon at a flat ₹5/min with telephony billed separately by your own carrier, Edesy at ₹6/min pay-as-you-go plus $0.07/min telephony, and Botsense at ₹7/min on the Growth plan that names Tamil.
Is Tamil charged extra compared with English or Hindi?
Not by Dvaarik. Tamil is billed at ₹2 per minute, exactly the same as English and Hindi, because Tamil is one of the 22 scheduled Indian languages covered by the base Bharat Standard tier — there is no language premium, no language package and no higher plan to move to. Several India vendors do structure it differently: Agni by Ravan.ai publishes "Hindi + English (Starter) · All 30+ Indian languages (Growth+)", and Botsense lists "Hindi + English support" on Starter with Tamil appearing on the Growth plan (both checked on the vendors' own pricing pages, 21 Jul 2026). Scalify Labs' pricing blog states that regional languages "typically add ₹0.10–₹0.20/min premium depending on the platform", which is their description of a market norm rather than their own published surcharge. Charging nothing extra for Tamil is not unique to Dvaarik — Trikon publishes Tamil inside a language list it labels "included free" at a flat ₹5/min.
Can it handle Tanglish and spoken Tamil, or only formal Tamil?
The agent handles spoken Tamil and code-mixed Tanglish, detects the language from the caller's first words with no press-1 menu, and follows a caller who switches between Tamil and English mid-sentence without restarting the conversation. This matters because Tamil has a well-documented split between the formal literary register and the everyday spoken register, and because Tamil speakers routinely keep words like appointment, booking, delivery and EMI in English inside an otherwise Tamil sentence. Dvaarik publishes no accuracy percentage for Tamil by region or accent, because no such figure has been measured — test it on a live call with your own callers in your own town before committing money.
What will my first month actually cost, including GST?
Dvaarik is self-serve SaaS today: there is no setup fee and no minimum commitment. You log in, add your services, staff, hours and knowledge, connect channels, and pay only for what your agents actually do.
| What | Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| AI voice calls | from ₹2/min | Simple per-minute billing on whole minutes; higher grades up to ₹5/min |
| AI chat | ₹2 per conversation | 24-hour window |
| Phone number + 1 concurrent line | ₹1,500 per 30 days | Includes up to 3 numbers; debited from credits |
| Social Plan — WhatsApp + Instagram agents + campaigns | ₹1,500 per 30 days | Only if you use those channels |
| WhatsApp message charges | ₹0 markup | Meta bills your own WhatsApp Business account directly |
The comparison above states the published row-by-row differences; read each row with its source, date, and qualifying notes.
Credits are prepaid and never expire; at zero balance agents pause gracefully, so there are no surprise bills. Agencies and developers can sell the same platform under their own brand through the white-label partner programme, and set their own client pricing.
Which India vendors publish a rate for Tamil calling, and what are they?
Almost none publish a Tamil-specific per-minute rate; what they publish is a general rate plus a statement of which tier includes Tamil. Read on the vendors' own pages on 21 Jul 2026: Trikon publishes a flat ₹5/min with Tamil inside a language list it labels "included free", with telephony billed separately by your own carrier; Edesy publishes ₹6/min pay-as-you-go with 8+ Indian languages, plus $0.07/min telephony and a ₹500 minimum recharge; Agni by Ravan.ai publishes Growth at ₹5,999/mo with 1,000 minutes and ₹6/min overage as the tier where all 30+ Indian languages sit; Botsense publishes ₹7/min on the Growth plan that names Tamil; VaniAgent publishes ₹4.5–5.5/min on a Metered Credits tier at ₹4,999/month and claims 27 Indian languages; Bolna publishes 6.00¢/min, displayed on its own page as ₹5.52/min, with telephony and an unpublished platform fee on top. SquadStack publishes no rupee figure at all and states that its per-minute rate depends on language mix. Competitor pricing in this market moves within weeks, so re-check any figure against the live page.
Is an AI agent cheaper than hiring a Tamil-speaking receptionist?
On money alone it usually is at moderate call volumes — a Dvaarik agent at 1,200 billed minutes a month costs ₹4,400 from month 4, which is ₹2,400 of talk time at ₹2/min plus the ₹1,500 number charge — but the two are poor substitutes and better complements. A Tamil-speaking person at a counter reads hesitation, recognises a returning family, handles walk-ins and negotiates, and an AI agent does none of that. The agent is worth having for the call at 9pm, the second caller during the lunch rush, and the follow-up list nobody gets to. Dvaarik publishes no salary comparison figure for Tamil Nadu on this page because it has not verified one.
Is there a subscription, a minimum volume or a lock-in?
Dvaarik is self-serve SaaS today: there is no setup fee and no minimum commitment. You log in, add your services, staff, hours and knowledge, connect channels, and pay only for what your agents actually do.
| What | Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| AI voice calls | from ₹2/min | Simple per-minute billing on whole minutes; higher grades up to ₹5/min |
| AI chat | ₹2 per conversation | 24-hour window |
| Phone number + 1 concurrent line | ₹1,500 per 30 days | Includes up to 3 numbers; debited from credits |
| Social Plan — WhatsApp + Instagram agents + campaigns | ₹1,500 per 30 days | Only if you use those channels |
| WhatsApp message charges | ₹0 markup | Meta bills your own WhatsApp Business account directly |
The comparison above states the published row-by-row differences; read each row with its source, date, and qualifying notes.
Credits are prepaid and never expire; at zero balance agents pause gracefully, so there are no surprise bills. Agencies and developers can sell the same platform under their own brand through the white-label partner programme, and set their own client pricing.
Tell us your call volume on WhatsApp and we will work out your real monthly number before you commit to anything.
Log in to Dvaarik
LoginTagged

Written by
Rohith Sriramula
Founder & CEO, Dvaarik AI
A laid-off engineer who went all in on Dvaarik AI. He builds the platform and product workflows from hands-on work with Indian businesses, not theory.